21st Century Progressive

30,759 notes

Why didn’t the Eagles just take the Fellowship directly to Mordor?
Eagles are very proud and noble creatures who refused to get involved in the wars of men. Gandalf was only able to ride them because he was a Maiar, a semi-divine spirit, who the Lord of the Eagles, Gwaihir, owed a favor because Gandalf had once saved him from a poisoned arrow.
The Fellowship was supposed to travel in secret. Sauron only knew that the Ring had left Gollum’s cave for the Shire, and was now somewhere else. Large eagles flying into Mordor would have tipped off Sauron and, most importantly, the Nazgul, which no creature could out-maneuver. The Nazgul would have killed the eagles and taken the Ring to Sauron.

Why didn’t the Eagles just take the Fellowship directly to Mordor?

  1. Eagles are very proud and noble creatures who refused to get involved in the wars of men. Gandalf was only able to ride them because he was a Maiar, a semi-divine spirit, who the Lord of the Eagles, Gwaihir, owed a favor because Gandalf had once saved him from a poisoned arrow.
  2. The Fellowship was supposed to travel in secret. Sauron only knew that the Ring had left Gollum’s cave for the Shire, and was now somewhere else. Large eagles flying into Mordor would have tipped off Sauron and, most importantly, the Nazgul, which no creature could out-maneuver. The Nazgul would have killed the eagles and taken the Ring to Sauron.

Filed under lotr Lord of the rings One does not simply The Hobbit loopholes Gwaihir Boromir GAndalf Eagles

  1. her-own-kind-of-revenge reblogged this from 21stcenturyprogressive
  2. asianfrustration13 reblogged this from 21stcenturyprogressive
  3. spiffyjiffy reblogged this from klainelynch
  4. klainelynch reblogged this from inthehouseofstark
  5. minimal23 reblogged this from whoviangater
  6. witch-of-the-northern-reach reblogged this from whoviangater
  7. miss-undiscovered-genius reblogged this from whoviangater
  8. emjayrad reblogged this from whoviangater
  9. whoviangater reblogged this from notaredshirt
  10. meghanjh reblogged this from ladyofhimring
  11. sweetladyjustice reblogged this from ladyofhimring
  12. ladyofhimring reblogged this from speedymakac
  13. re-gaining-unconsciousness reblogged this from theladyisafuckingdandy
  14. mew77 reblogged this from thelittle-hobbit
  15. ifthisisyourthing reblogged this from anfielding
  16. vampspaz reblogged this from puffoftheturkey
  17. seleniceria reblogged this from benedikutokanbabatchi
  18. togoboldlyandpropser reblogged this from so-says-the-moon-emperor
  19. so-says-the-moon-emperor reblogged this from arminalert
  20. rainbow-unicorn-butt reblogged this from old-yodalicious
  21. old-yodalicious reblogged this from wanderingoff
  22. smaug-the-fashionable-dragon reblogged this from 21stcenturyprogressive
  23. wizkidstiles reblogged this from tomunio89
  24. tomunio89 reblogged this from glenien
  25. wakingsleepinglaughingweeping reblogged this from theblacksonfive
  26. pippintook22 reblogged this from shartinfreeman
  27. astralfeces reblogged this from allthingshyper
  28. theblacksonfive reblogged this from allthingshyper
  29. the-winter-fae reblogged this from allthingshyper